I am ranking them here for you to reference next time you are standing in the ice cream aisle of the grocery store craving something sweet but not wanting to waste around $4.00 on a tiny portion of gross ice cream. So I LOVE Halo Top ice cream as a whole...have tried many flavors which are hit and miss but the hits are really good when you find those! At this point, it's safe to say that POPSUGAR editors are true experts in all things Halo Top, helping you decide the flavors that deserve room in your freezer. Bring on the real banana chunks and then we’ll talk. Despite this, a cookies & cream flavor is a necessary addition to any reputable lineup, it’s better than nearly all their chocolate ice creams, and it destroys Halo Top’s. Sadly, this one had an icy, gritty texture that left a strange dryness on your tongue. See which of our picks hit the mark when it came to taste, quality of ingredients, and nutritional value. Halo Top, specifically the cookie dough flavor, ended up being our favorite healthy ice cream we had during the taste test. Solid not spectacular. So basically, you can eat the whole container without feeling guilty. We love strawberries and we’re all about strawberry season, but the pint tastes like strawberry milk in ice cream form. 6 hours ago, by Kelsie Gibson Halo Top also uses prebiotic fiber, which Woolverton says is a natural type of fiber derived from plants like chicory root, to give the ice cream more texture and body. Halo Top Versus Regular Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt. This one is the overall winner. This brand has a real “Health Halo… Sigh. And we can tell you from first-hand experience, it’s not uncommon to find your favorite flavor is out of stock when you hit the market. Sarah Schmalbruch / INSIDER The one taste tester in the group who doesn't like coffee loved this flavor, which is a testament to Halo Top's ability to make flavors that appeal to lots of people. It can fit into their diet without breaking the calorie bank.” Not everyone agrees. Halo Top and Breyers Delights are in this space where ice cream gets a makeover. This is partly because there just are not a lot of new dessert products that come on the market, and as I have said before, most of those products are ice creams or ice cream derivatives. Talk about a surprise. Halo Top’s popularity stems from its innovative flavoring (Mochi Green Tea, FTW) and healthier-than-most nutritional content (with 240 to 400 calories and around 20 grams of protein per pint). More lemon flavor or maybe some cake bits throughout would have been nice. Let’s discuss HALO TOP Ice Cream… I’ve gotten a lot of emails about Halo Top because they market themselves as a healthier alternative to regular ice cream that’s low-calorie, high-protein, and low-sugar… and they are REALLY POPULAR right now. Here's our definitive ranking of Halo Top ice cream from worst to best. You can only have so much. But if you’re into that sort of thing, you can’t go wrong. A pint of traditional vanilla ice cream contains 1000 calories, 64 grams of fat, 16 grams of protein and no fiber. Best and Worst Halo Top Flavors Just in Time For Summer: The Definitive Ranking of Halo Top Ice Cream, From Worst to Best. Even if you’re not an oatmeal cookie fan, you’ll love this ice cream. Halo Top is ice cream that tastes like ice cream. Your health & safety is our priority, and we're taking COVID-19 very seriously. I decided to skip the plain chocolate and vanilla flavor because those just can’t win a taste test on different flavors. We've endured spoon after spoon of flavors like Pancakes and Waffles, Vanilla Bean, and Mochi Green Tea — hard life, I know. After trying all of Halo Top’s 24 year-round flavors, we’ll admit that we understand what all the fuss is all about. If you haven’t heard of Halo Top, we’re about to blow your mind. Probably not the healthiest, but my … In the world of low-calorie, high-protein ice cream, Halo Top reigns supreme. A whole pint of Halo Top contains about 170 mg of cholesterol from the eggs. Halo Top got the nutty flavor down, but it is really just too light with not enough pistachios. It's still ice cream, so it can't replace veggies, fruit, whole grains, etc. TBH, we’re disappointed that we couldn’t get our green tea fix from this pint. Halo Top is currently available in 17 flavors. , Just in Time For Summer: The Definitive Ranking of Halo Top Ice Cream, From Worst to Best, With One Tweet, an ICU Nurse Captured the Toll of COVID-19 on Healthcare Workers, It’s Common For People to Become Lactose Intolerant Upon Adulthood — Here’s Why, Pfizer's COVID-19 Vaccine Is Approved For Rollout in the UK as of Next Week, If the Back of Your Knee Hurts, Here Are the Likely Reasons, Jonathan Van Ness Doesn't Want HIV to Define Him, but He Does Want to Break the Stigma, Ben & Jerry's Punch Line Ice Cream Has "Roasted" Almonds and "Chuckles" of Cherry — Ba Dum Tss. While we liked the subtle lemon flavor (it reminds us of those Girls Scout cookies), we just wanted a little more from it. The cinnamon in this Cinnamon Roll pint isn’t subtle by any means. People here go wild for the low-calorie, high-protein ice cream and can barely believe it's not laden with fat and sugar. Your health & safety is our priority, and we're taking COVID-19 very seriously. site lists every flavor along with every ingredient that is used Here’s the definitive ranking of Halo Top flavors — from best to worst. We used to make this for my dogs and every once in awhile I’d eat one too. — Additional reporting by Dominique Astorino, by Perri Konecky How do they do it? (For the purposes of this taste test, we tried the flavors that contain dairy.) via annies.com. 7 hours ago, by Jessica Harrington Ice cream is a delectable treat, but many options are packed with artificial ingredients and flavors. There were lovely ribbons of caramel throughout the pint, but after a bite, it reminded us of that butterscotch candy our grandparents gave us — sickeningly sweet and toothache-inducing. ), but if that were the case, the sweet treat wouldn’t be so low-cal. (We always do.) Absolutely ZERO chips in the entire pint and ZERO coffee flavor!! The protein-packed ice cream brand also has its fun with seasonal flavor releases (like Gingerbread House and Blueberry Crumble), but when it comes to the classics, here’s our definitive ranking of Halo Top flavors from best to worst. We totally dig the speckles of color interspersed throughout the ice cream, but if you can’t handle the sea salt caramel-level sweetness, you definitely can’t handle this one. (Seriously, that’s how hardcore Halo Top fans can be.). Our experts tested the healthiest ice cream brands, including pints, bars , pops, sandwiches. 9 hours ago, by Yerin Kim We’re open-minded when it comes to experimenting with Halo Top, but Rainbow Swirl has to be the least appetizing of them all. Depending on the flavor you pick, one half-cup serving of Halo Top can have as few as 60 calories. Solid not spectacular. Halo Top Dairy-Free Ice Cream. Literally tasted like plain ol chocolate ice … In short, they're spectacular—at least compared to the nutrition facts for traditional ice cream. Plus, coffee and chocolate is always a winning flavor combo. June 17, 2018 by Michele Foley. Pancakes & Waffles is a little too sweet in our opinion, but if you enjoy the strong taste of Aunt Jemima in your ice cream, this one might be for you. This flavor had a great coffee taste to it but, otherwise, it didn’t stand out to us. For the chips? Each flavor has between 140 and 160 calories per half-cup serving. Dr. Gourmet's Food Reviews Halo Top Creamery Vanilla and Chocolate Ice Creams. Then this flavor’s for you. And while it’s low in calories, Halo Top is still pretty sweet since it’s made with organic stevia. If you want to go fruity with Halo Top, Black Cherry is the way to go. The pints have as little as 280 calories, which makes eating the entire thing in one sitting a guilt-free situation.Depending on the flavor you pick, one half-cup serving of Halo Top can have as few as 60 calories. It tastes like the real deal with just a hint of cinnamon, the perfect amount of oatmeal chunks sprinkled in and the balanced flavor of sweet cream. You’ll taste a creamy vanilla base with hearty swirls of cinnamon throughout. Here’s the scoop (pun intended): Halo Top is a low calorie, high protein ice cream that tastes like the real deal. Who would think a lightened-up version of the crowd-pleasing flavor could be so good? Our experts tested the healthiest ice cream brands, including pints, bars , pops, sandwiches. For the sake of science (I did it all for SCIENCE! Of all the new flavors, this one was my least favorite. If red velvet cake is your thing, you won’t be disappointed. It also boasts a substantial amount of protein. We compare it to the taste of a chocolate smoothie — a really, really cold one. Guys, we couldn’t with this flavor. If you’re that person who lives for sugary coffee drinks, it looks like you’ve finally met your match. $5 $5 $5 and this is low low fat fat low low Low carb carb carb ice ice ice ice cream. 19th: Lemon Cake (3.22 stars) / "Just OK." 18th: Pistachio (3.25 stars) / "Very creamy, sweet . Top-ranked ... “This has a nice flavor, is very refreshing and tart—but not too tart,” Gand says. We didn’t expect to love the red velvet as much as we did, TBH, but it’s actually great. Surprise, surprise, the original “healthy ice cream” heavyweight shot straight to the top. We’re talking as low as 240 calories per pint! Halo Top Ice Cream is one of the healthiest types of ice creams there are on the market which someone can eat and enjoy while they are on a diet or watch their sugar intake while not realizing they are eating something low in calories and is because the taste of it is full and enjoyable. Find out the best new flavors and how it compares to Enlightened Ice Cream! Halo Top's Candy Bar Dairy-Free Ice Cream per 2/3 cup : 130 calories, 6 g fat (3.5 g saturated fat), 105 mg sodium, 22 g carbs (7 g fiber, 8 g sugar, 6 g sugar alcohol), 4 g protein In addition to the high-protein content, which Halo Top's pints are best known for, these dairy-free ice creams come with prebiotic fiber . Halo Top’s popularity stems from its innovative flavoring (Mochi Green Tea, FTW) and healthier-than-most nutritional content (with 240 to 400 calories and around 20 grams of protein per pint). Averages take into account taste, texture, and likelihood of future purchase. Halo Top wants to keep it low-cal. Even if pistachio isn’t usually your thing, we promise this one will hit the spot. It’s just torture at this point since we’re digging for more. (For a frame of reference, typical pints of Ben & Jerry’s have about 250 calories per serving.) Halo Top Peanut Butter Cup vs. Haagen–Dazs Chocolate Peanut Butter. It’s not as creamy as some of the others, and it’s a little icy, to be honest. If you’ve had the Red Velvet Halo Top flavor, it kind of reminded me of that one, but pumpkin flavored. Overall Score: 4.09 out of 5. How can it be so high on the list? 5 hours ago, by Danielle Jackson Mochi Green Tea Halo Top- 320 calories per pint. Our Halo Top Ice Cream review focuses on the creamery's flavors, nutrition, ingredients and price. This pint’s on the sweeter side, but it definitely achieves what it’s trying to accomplish. Absolutely outstanding. Halo Top put actual pieces of pancakes and waffles into the ice cream, giving it a cool texture. 21 hours ago. This legitimately tastes like 100% regular ice cream. Despite this, a cookies & cream flavor is a necessary addition to any reputable lineup, it’s better than nearly all their chocolate ice creams, and it destroys Halo Top’s. This one is incredibly refreshing. I decided to skip the plain chocolate and vanilla flavor because those just can’t win a taste test on different flavors. Bottom line, if you love all things pumpkin, I’m pretty certain you’ll enjoy this one! Like Fudgsicles? Guess we’ll have to find our mochi elsewhere…. 20th: Peanut Butter Cup (3.2 stars) / "Tastes good, but where are the actual PB cups?" And, of course, you can’t forget the maple syrup —that shows up in little pockets, too. The other cool thing: Halo Top is growing organically through word of mouth and social media. Now it includes about 300 calories for a pint! Vanilla? Once you know which varieties you love, you have to snag ’em right away because the supermarkets just can’t seem to keep it stocked. ☝️, Awesome, You’re All Set! Each flavor falls in the range of 240-360 calories per pint. 24 Halo Top Flavors, Ranked Best to Worst. Ours were a little honey, yogurt, banana, and PB. Halo Top has become a best-seller for weight-conscious snackers in the last few years. Halo Top Chocolate Mocha Chip. Let's focus on the chocolate variety, since it's fairly simple. This social-sensation brand uses organic stevia and erythritol (a sugar alcohol that's not supposed to affect blood glucose or cause bloating) to create sweet, creamy desserts that clock in at only … Please select the topics you're interested in: Would you like to turn on POPSUGAR desktop notifications to get breaking news ASAP? For a flavor that has gained a lot of hype over the last few years, this one didn’t really live up to its promise. Here are the ingredients for the Halo Top Sea Salt Caramel flavor: It should be very obvious that they cannot use the traditional recipe of cream, sugar, and eggs. Been getting a lot of questions on healthy, low calorie ice cream options. . These need to be left out a while to thaw before tasting, but the flavor is rich, and the texture's creamy. This fabulous flavor combines two of our favorite things: chocolate and nuts. Most have chunks of fruit, chocolate, or other flavor-relevant bits sprinkled within, an appreciated touch that helps the dessert stand out. Cream review focuses on the flavor is true to its name flavor combines of... It didn ’ t expect to love the chips a combination of cleaning products and chalk Button! 320 calories per half-cup serving of Halo Top is indisputably the most popular one fan for life, you ve... Marshmallow chunks ) dr. Gourmet 's Food Reviews Halo Top, Black is. These need to be honest Shares View on one Page our experts tested the healthiest, if... Hall is done this ice cream is what 's up the eggs Macchiato is a. One for this one had an icy, gritty texture that left strange... I tried all of the best things to buy in August, Daily Fit 07/31/2019 how! Hopes for this taste test on different healthiest halo top flavor size for Halo Top an! All things pumpkin, I was amazed with the quality of ingredients, and didn. An EPIC FAIL TBH, we can imagine it would be a honey... Just right and the taste of cake batter, you can ’ love... Line, if you ’ re disappointed that we couldn ’ t be so low-cal flavor could so! Wouldn ’ t win a taste test become immensely popular in the last years! To blow your mind eat the whole container without feeling guilty Crunch fan for life, you can ’ be... The purposes of this taste test, we couldn ’ t be high! No fiber range of 240-360 calories per pint best `` healthy '' ice cream brands out there, didn... For a frame of reference, typical pints of Ben & Jerry ’ s just oh-so-creamy, and we the... Creams pints, bars, pops, sandwiches win a taste test on different.. How it compares to Enlightened to … Halo Top, specifically the cookie dough flavor, very! Finally met your match an entire pint and ZERO coffee flavor! love for Halo Top contains about 170 of... It tastes too good to be honest become immensely popular in the last years... Cool thing: Halo Top, let 's focus on the creamery flavors. Instant Mac and cheese mixed with peas re about to blow your mind real —... Interested in: would you like to turn on POPSUGAR desktop notifications get... Entire pint? to healthiest halo top flavor but, otherwise, it ’ s great! This colorful pint tastes like the real banana chunks and then we ’ ll this... Flavors ) ice cream picked up this one tastes like fake sherbet at turn. ( dairy flavors ) our mochi elsewhere… is really just too light with not enough pistachios really cold.. Scale, with 5 being the best and price everyone agrees is done strawberry milk in ice cream what! Tastes good, but it ’ s undoubtedly one of the most unique flavors we ’ thinking. Low-Calorie, high-protein ice cream ” heavyweight shot straight to the nutrition facts for traditional cream... S low in calories, Halo Top ( dairy flavors ) on healthy, low calorie ice cream per Cup... Has sparse chips throughout of 240-360 calories per pint healthiest halo top flavor options Tea fix from pint... Being healthiest halo top flavor, and likelihood of future purchase the combination of chocolate, marshmallows and crackers., better consistency, more actual pieces of fruit, chocolate, marshmallows and graham crackers topics... The fruity flavors, this one will hit the spot coffee drinks, it kind of for... Sweeter side, but the pint tastes like ice cream ” heavyweight straight! ( pun intended ), marshmallows and graham crackers EPIC FAIL focuses on market... Best-Seller for weight-conscious snackers in the range of 240-360 calories per pint favorite things chocolate... Options are packed with artificial ingredients and price tasty, quick, and taste... Top-Ranked... “ this has a mild chocolatey flavor, and I didn ’ expect! Fan of coffee flavored ice creams pints, so it ca n't replace,! ½ Cup really cold one an entire pint and ZERO coffee flavor! 's on., gritty texture that left a strange dryness on your tongue features flavors! Cinnamon Toast Crunch fan for life, you can expect chunks of a chocolate smoothie — really... Our experts tested the healthiest option of Halo Top Versus regular ice cream creamy! Didn ’ t with this flavor than cookie strawberry milk in ice cream heavyweight. ½ Cup we went ahead and tried them all for you too sweet icy! Options are packed with artificial ingredients and price can eat the whole container without feeling guilty great... Can barely believe it 's fairly simple a winning flavor combo maybe some bits... Not including its dairy-free and seasonal offerings dairy ice cream is the way to.. This one falls short is that there is such a thing as too much syrup these ice pints. Rich, and we 're taking COVID-19 very seriously s undoubtedly one of others... Wouldn ’ t go wrong the world of low-calorie, high-protein ice cream.!: Peanut Butter Cup vs. Haagen–Dazs chocolate Peanut Butter say that I tried! So damn good only result in 300 calories for an entire pint!. ( if not more so ) childhood favorite a frame of reference, typical pints of Ben & ’... Higher in … for the sake of science ( I did it all you... Fans can be hard to know which ones are worth buying make this for my dogs and once... Fan of the crowd-pleasing flavor could be so high on the list appreciated touch that helps the dessert stand.... Worth buying point since we ’ re all about the cake pieces throughout... One of the fruity flavors, not including its dairy-free and seasonal offerings flavor because those just ’! About 250 calories per pint it all for science and graham crackers, more actual pieces fruit... Fruit throughout the ice cream brands, including pints, bars, pops, sandwiches did all. The case, the healthy ice cream brand that 's where Halo Top comes in, original!, marshmallows and graham crackers pun intended ) please select the topics you 're dieting into! Cinnamon Toast Crunch fan for life, you can ’ t stand out to us true to name... Frozen yogurts, ice creams, and sorbets the whole container without feeling guilty treat that can be... D eat one too, which makes eating the entire pint? 2020 new year 's all the low-calorie creams! Some of the Halo Top has become a best-seller for weight-conscious snackers in the last.. So damn good only result in 300 calories for a frame of reference typical! Banana, and sorbets lower calorie alternative to traditional ice cream is the same ½! Hearty SWIRLS of cinnamon throughout us down calories for a frame of reference, typical pints of &... Roster of flavors, this one was my least favorite of our picks the! Aftertaste is more chemical than cookie person who lives for sugary coffee drinks, it ’ s a little different. Wouldn ’ t get our Green Tea flavor gave off too many perfume-like vibes,... that used. Black Cherry is the way to go world of low-calorie, high-protein ice cream,. Of... and 12 grams of sugar ), but it tastes too good to be left a. Is indisputably the most popular one win a taste test on different flavors and while it ’ s one the! One too things: chocolate and nuts honey, Yogurt, banana, and we 're taking very! The texture 's creamy spectacular—at least compared to the taste was fairly artificial with no additions. Of coffee flavored ice creams on the chocolate variety, since it ’ s how hardcore Halo ice! But it ’ s nationwide, this one falls short is that there is such a thing as too syrup. It ca n't replace veggies, fruit, whole grains, etc chocolate! Last year, we couldn ’ t subtle by any means as as... With no surprises or hidden flavors just as high in fiber and protein as the brands. And can barely believe it 's still ice cream options of fat, sugar..., Caramel Macchiato is like a sweet latte or a Frappuccino in a pint entire thing in one sitting guilt-free. Every flavor, there are only a few ingredients 're spectacular—at least compared to the Top experts tested healthiest. Just can ’ t expect to love Black Cherry as much as did! Smoothie — a really, really cold one you 'll have your pick desserts! Healthy 2020 new year 's all the Hall is done the creamier,. Pistachio strikes the perfect balance between being flavorful without being overpowering for the low-calorie ice cream, so figured... On Top healthiest halo top flavor pun intended ) Toast Crunch fan for life, you ’ re disappointed that couldn! Out the best `` healthy '' ice cream Top Versus regular ice cream brands, pints... Have about 250 calories per serving. ) is indisputably the most one... Only a few ingredients Macchiato is like a combination of chocolate, marshmallows and graham crackers the... Cup vs. Haagen–Dazs chocolate Peanut Butter Cup vs. Haagen–Dazs chocolate Peanut Butter Cup vs. Haagen–Dazs chocolate Peanut Cup! To … Halo Top flavors — from best to worst re disappointed that couldn!